This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License, permitting all non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Sea ice and icebergs are the dominant transport agents for sand-sized material to the central Arctic Ocean. However, few studies have investigated concurrent changes in the silt-sized fraction of Arctic sediments. Here we present an analysis of the coarse fraction content and silt grain size composition from middle and late Quaternary sediments recovered from the Lomonosov Ridge, in the central Arctic Ocean. A significant shift in the grain size record occurs at the marine isotope stage (MIS) 6/7 boundary, where larger amplitude variability in the sand fraction is seen in glacial and stadial periods. Below the MIS6/7 boundary, variations in the coarse fraction content are less pronounced, but prominent changes in the silt size fraction appear to define glacial and interglacial periods. Throughout the record, the percent weight of sortable silt in the fine fraction (SS % wtfines), sortable silt mean size, and coarse silt content all increase as the >63 µm % wt content increases. This is consistent with observations of grain size spectra obtained from modern sea-ice samples, and indicates a strong overprint from sea ice on the silt distribution. The mechanism by which this sea-ice signal is preserved in the sediments across glacial and interglacial periods remains unclear. We suggest that the coarsening of silt-sized material during glacial periods could be attributed to either the entrainment of larger size fractions during suspension/anchor ice formation when sea levels are lowered, or diminished input and advection of fine fraction material during glacial periods.
In mid- to high-latitude settings, the abundance of terrigenous coarse-grained material (>63 µm) in sediments is commonly used as a proxy for the relative proportion of ice-rafted material (Polyak et al.
The large proportion and selective entrainment of fine fraction material in sea ice generates ambiguity in identifying the sea-ice rafted component of Arctic seafloor sediments. It also presents a challenge for identifying current related sorting of the fine fraction material. Unravelling the relative influence of different transport and sorting processes on Arctic sea floor sediments could greatly advance our understanding of sea ice and circulation changes in the geologic past. However, we still lack tightly calibrated age models for central Arctic sediments, that would allow detailed flux comparisons across glacial and interglacial periods, or between cores from different oceanographic settings (Backman et al.
Here we present the first detailed look at variations in the silt fraction of middle and late Quaternary sediments from the circumpolar region of the Lomonosov Ridge. The records were generated on cores HLY0503-18JPC and HLY0503-18TC, recovered during the HOTRAX expedition in 2005 (Darby et al.
Cores HLY0503-18JPC and HLY0503-18TC were recovered from 2598 m water depth, in a ca. 2700 m deep Intra Basin on the Lomonosov Ridge (
Schematic map of the Arctic Ocean showing the site of Core 18, ACEX, 96/12-1PC and Ps-2185-6 on the Lomonosov Ridge. A three-dimensional image of the Intra Basin is shown in the top-left corner, with the paths of the Canadian Basin Deep Water (CBDW) and the Eurasian Basin Deep Water (EBDW) marked in grey and black, respectively. The bathymetry is from the International Bathymetric Chart of the Arctic Ocean, version 2.0 (Jakobsson et al.
The jumbo piston core HLY0503-18JPC and the trigger weight core HLY0503-18TC (88°27′N 146°34′E) were used in this study. The cores were retrieved from USCGC
For the grain size analysis, a continuous set of 2 cm samples was taken from a u-channel. Sub-samples (3–4 g) of these were wet sieved through a 63-µm mesh. The sieving liquid was deionized water saturated with CaCO3 in order to preserve calcareous microfossils. The coarse fraction was dried on the mesh in an oven and allowed to cool before weighing. The fine fraction (<63 µm) was collected in beakers where it was allowed to settle. The water was siphoned out and the samples were centrifuged. A dispersion liquid (NaPO3) was added to the samples and they were thoroughly suspended using sonification. Each sample was analysed using 0.08 phi bin size divisions for the 1–63 µm fraction in the Sedigraph 5100 (Micromeritics, Norcross, GA, USA). The Sedigraph is based on the settling velocity principle and has been shown to provide reliable estimates of the sortable silt abundance and mean size when the % wt of sortable silt is >5% (Bianchi et al.
Silt statistical parameters (mean, sorting, skewness and kurtosis) were determined for the 2–63 µm size fraction using the GRADISTAT software (Blott & Pye
A stratigraphic correlation with the composite section from the Integrated Ocean Drilling Programs Expedition 302, the Arctic Coring Expedition (ACEX), was established using the multi-sensor core logging derived bulk density and magnetic susceptibility records, the alignment of key lithologic features, and in the upper few metres, variations in the coarse fraction content (
(a) Correlation of bulk density between Core 18 and ACEX, and tie points used to develop the chronology of the ACEX record (O'Regan et al.
The stratigraphic correlation allows the Quaternary age model presented for the ACEX record (O'Regan et al.
The weight percent coarse fraction (>63 µm), weight percent sortable silt in the fine fraction (SS % wtfines; 10–63 µm as defined by McCave, Manighetti, & Robinson
Downhole plots of the bulk density, >63 µm % wt from sieving (green), mean size of the fines (red), SS % wt, sortable silt mean and the kurtosis, sorting and skewness calculated on the silt distributions.
Statistical parameters measured on the silt-sized fraction all exhibit trends consistent with variations in the mean grain size of the fine fraction and SS % wtfines. Intervals with greater SS % wtfines also exhibit lower values of kurtosis (flatter distributions), higher values for sorting (less sorted) and silt distributions that are positively (fine) skewed (i.e., they have a tail of finer material). The silt distributions within the coarse-grained intervals in the upper 4.4 mcd do not appear more poorly sorted than the coarser grained intervals below 4.4 mcd, but tend to be more strongly skewed (
To illustrate how grain size variations change across the proposed glacial and interglacial periods, the same records are presented on the mapped ACEX age model (
Age-calibrated records of the parameters shown in
Above 4.4 mcd, which has consistently been interpreted as the base of MIS6 in sediment cores from the central Lomonosov Ridge (O'Regan
Bivariate plots of the SS % wtfines, sortable silt mean and coarse fraction content in Core 18 illustrate a bias towards coarser silt grain sizes as the coarse fraction content increases (
Cross-plots of sortable silt parameters (SS % wtfines, sortable silt mean) and the coarse fraction content (>63 µm % wt from sieving). (a) SS % wtfines and >63 µm % wt (b) sortable silt mean and >63 µm % wt (c) sortable silt mean and SS % wtfines. Black dots correspond to sediments older than MIS6 and grey dots sediments from MIS6 and younger.
In order to better visualize how the texture of the silt fraction changes as a function of the >63 µm % wt, frequency plots were generated for the fine fraction material in samples having coarse fraction contents of <5% wt, 5–10% wt and >10% wt (
Average size frequency plots for sediments from Core 18 (n is the number of samples averaged). All plots represent the 1–63 µm fractions presented in phi units. Frequency spectra are shown for all the data and compared to sediments from MIS 1–6 and older than MIS6. Spectra are subdivided into populations of samples having <5%, 5–10% and >10 wt % of coarse fraction material. The bottom pane illustrates interpreted modes of sediment texture related to sea ice and iceberg related deposition in the Arctic, and how they may combine to form a mixed sea ice–iceberg grain size signal (Clark & Hanson
The relationship between statistical parameters describing the silt distribution (mean, sorting, skewness and kurtosis) and the >63 µm % wt of the sample are further illustrated by a series of bivariate plots (
Bivariate plots of silt statistical parameters, with samples coded depending on the % wt >63 µm; triangles ≤5%, squares=5–10% and circles ≥10%. Overlain are results from a similar analysis conducted on 33 sea-ice samples from the Fram Strait (Dethleff & Kuhlmann
Detailed studies of the grain size distribution of the fine fraction are not common in the Arctic Ocean where there is a tendency to focus on the coarse fraction content of the sediment as a proxy for ice rafting. Coarse fraction data from the Quaternary section of the ACEX record, and other shorter sediment cores from the region (i.e., 96-12/1-PC, PS-2185-6;
The abundance of >63 µm sediments in Core 18 reveals a similar trend to other records from the Lomonosov Ridge, with the most prominent coarse-grained intervals occurring during the last two glacial cycles. These intervals are associated with iceberg rafting events from the Barents–Kara ice sheet during MIS6, 5/4 and during the early period of MIS3 (Jakobsson et al.
The absence of similarly pronounced coarse-grained intervals in underlying sediments of Core 18, suggests a less pronounced influence by icebergs during glacial periods predating MIS6. Their absence has also complicated the clear identification of glacial–interglacial periods and the development of cyclostratigraphic-based age models. To this end, the more pronounced and higher frequency variation in the silt fraction identified by this study (
The mean sortable silt size and SS % wtfines have been successfully applied as palaeo-current proxies in the North Atlantic (McCave, Manighetti, & Beveridge
Recently, Hoffman et al. (
A linear correlation between the wt % in different silt size bins with the >63 µm % wt reveals that it is primarily the coarse silt (>20 µm) that is positively correlated to the coarse fraction content (
(a) Linear correlation coefficients between % wtsilt in silt size bins and the >63 µm % wt from sieving. (b) Cross-plot of the coarse silt abundance (% wtsilt) and the >63 µm % wt from sieving. (c) Cross-plot of sorting of the silt fraction and the coarse silt abundance (% wtsilt) illustrating that intervals with higher abundances of coarse silt have less well sorted silt distributions. Overlain on (b) and (c) are results from sea-ice samples collected in Fram Strait (Dethleff & Kuhlmann
While our results illustrate that coarsening of fine fraction material accompanies an increase in the coarse fraction content, there remains some uncertainty as to how this signal is preserved and what drives the observed changes across glacial and interglacial cycles. There are three possible ways we envisage these changes occurring, none of which are mutually exclusive. The first is the delivery of more ice-rafted debris during glacial periods, which results in an overall coarsening of the sediment. However, except for the glacial/stadial stages between MIS 1–6, the current age model indicates lower relative sedimentation rates during glacial periods (O'Regan et al.
A second method may be the cessation of fine fraction transport by either intermediate water currents or nepheloid layers (Rutgers van der Loeff et al.
A final possible explanation is that during glacial intervals, lowering of sea level allows either coarser grained sediment to be incorporated into sea ice via suspension freezing, or there is a relative increase in the amount of anchor ice, which can incorporate a wider and coarser range of grain sizes (Reimnitz et al. 1987; Darby et al.
Testing these hypotheses requires additional analyses of the fine fraction material from stratigraphically aligned cores that today sit in different water masses. For example, while Core 18 sits in the Intra Basin where Arctic Deep Waters pass between the Makarov and Amundsen basins, cores from the crest of the Lomonosov Ridge are near the base of modern Arctic Intermediate Water. A comparative analysis of the fine fraction component from these different oceanographic settings may help identify vertical (ice-rafted debris) and lateral (current transported) inputs, and how they change across glacial and interglacial periods. To further isolate the sea-ice and iceberg related contribution to the silt distribution, analyses should extend to coarser size fractions. Finally, testing if sea-level variations across glacial and interglacial periods coarsen the silt distribution in Arctic sediments could be achieved by investigating sediments deposited prior to the establishment of large Northern Hemisphere ice sheets.
This study provides a long-term perspective on middle to late Quaternary grain size variations within the fine fraction of sediments deposited on the Lomonosov Ridge. It uses the proposed ACEX age model to investigate how changes in the silt distribution of sediments changes between glacial and interglacial periods. The principal findings are that throughout the ca. 1 million year record, the SS % wtfines, sortable silt mean, and coarse silt content all increase as the >63 µm % wt content increases. This appears to be similar to findings from modern sea ice samples and highlights the strong imprint that sea ice deposition has on the fine fraction distribution. As previously illustrated by Hass (
The authors would like to thank the Swedish Research Secretariat, the captains and crews of the icebreakers USCGC