Giles Land—a mystery for S.A. Andrée and other early Arctic explorers

Björn Lantz

doi:10.33265/polar.v38.3433

Björn Lantz Technology Management and Economics, Chalmers University of Technology

DOI: https://doi.org/10.33265/polar.v38.3433

Keywords: Kvitøya, Andrée expedition, Arctic exploration, Svalbard, maps

Abstract

After the initial discovery of Giles Land (Kvitøya, Svalbard) by Cornelis Giles in 1707, it was most likely never seen by anyone again until 1876. During this lengthy period, Giles Land evolved into an enigma as various explorers and cartographers came to very different conclusions about its probable location, character or even existence. In 1897, when the engineer Salomon August Andrée tried to return over the ice after his failed attempt to reach the North Pole in a balloon, he passed through an area approximately 160 km north of Kvitøya where Giles Land was indicated on his map. Andrée searched for it, but there was no land in sight. The main reason why Giles Land was erroneously positioned too far north was a conjecture by a German cartographer August Petermann in 1872. While there was some distrust of Petermann’s conjecture at the time, many also believed it. The erroneous understanding that Giles Land was located far north of Kvitøya was only finally dismissed in the 1930s. This article examines how this misunderstanding regarding the identity and location of Giles Land could arise and become entrenched.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Andrée S.A., Strindberg N. & Frænkel K. 1931. The Andrée diaries. London: John Lane the Bodley Head.

Barr W. 1977. The first Soviet high-latitude expedition. Arctic 30, 205–216, https://doi.org/10.14430/arctic2701.

Barrington D. 1818. The possibility of approaching the North Pole asserted. New York: James Eastburn & Co.

Bartholomew J.G. 1897. Physical chart of North Polar regions. Unpaginated map in F. Nansen: Farthest north. Vol. 1. New York: Harper and Brothers.

Baur C.F. 1870. Neueste Karte der Erde. Mit Rücksicht auf das Bedürfniss des Handelstandes. (Latest map of the Earth. With regard to the needs of trade.) Stuttgart: Verlag von Julius Mayer.

Bellin J.N. 1780 (1758). Carte du Spits-Berg suivant les Hollandois. (Map of Spitsbergen based on the Dutch.) Unpaginated map in J.-F. de La Harpe (1780): Abrégé de l’histoire générale des voyages. (Summary of the general history of travels.) Paris: Ménard et Desenne.

Brice A.M. 1896. The Jackson–Harmsworth Polar expedition. The Geographical Journal 8, 543–564, https://doi.org/10.2307/1774217.

Capelotti P.J. 2013. Shipwreck at Cape Flora. Calgary, AB: University of Calgary Press.

Collin C.E. 1877 (1876). Région arctique. (Arctic region.) Unpaginated map in L.V. de Saint Martin (1877): Atlas universel. (Universal Atlas.) Paris: Hachette.

Conway M. 1906. No man’s land: A history of Spitsbergen from its discovery in 1596 to the beginning of the scientific exploration of the country. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Doncker H. 1663. De zee-atlas ofte water-waereld. (The sea atlas or the water world.) Amsterdam: Henrick Doncker.

Dunér N. & Nordenskiöld A.E. 1865. Anteckningar till Spetsbergens geografi. (Notes on Spitsbergen geography.) Kungliga Svenska Vetenskapsakademiens Handlingar 6(5). Stockholm: Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences.

Dunér N., Malmgren A.J. & Nordenskiöld A.E. 1867. Svenska expeditioner till Spetsbergen och Jan Mayen åren 1863–64. (Swedish expeditions to Spitsbergen and Jan Mayen in 1863–64.) Stockholm: P.A. Norstedt & Söner.

Greely A.W. 1895. Handbook of Arctic discoveries. Boston: Roberts Brothers.

Jackson F.G. 1898. Three years’ exploration in Franz Josef Land. The Geographical Journal 11(2), 113–138, https://doi.org/10.2307/1774430.

Jackson F.G. 1899. A thousand days in the Arctic. London: Harper & Brothers.

Lantz B. 2018. Could the members of the 1897 Andrée balloon expedition have survived? Polar Record 54, 234–236, https://doi.org/10.1017/S0032247418000402.

Le Rouge G.-L. 1758. Atlas nouveau portatif a l’usage des militaires, collèges et du voyageur. (New portable atlas for military, college and traveler use.) Paris: Le Rouge & Prault Fils.

Leslie A. 1879. The Arctic voyages of Adolf Erik Nordenskiöld. London: MacMillan and Co.

Markham C.R. 1881. The voyages of William Baffin, 1612–1622. London: The Hakluyt Society.

Mills W.J. 2003. Exploring polar frontiers: a historical encyclopedia. Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIO Ltd.

Nansen F. 1897. Farthest north. New York: Harper and Brothers.

Nathorst A.G. 1896. Nansens och “Frams” återkomst. (The return of Nansen and the Fram) Ymer 16, 193–202.

Nathorst A.G. 1897. Gilies Land. The Geographical Journal 9(1), 101, https://doi.org/10.2307/1773656.

Petermann A.H. 1872. Gillis-Land, König Karl-Land und das Seeboden-Relief um Spitzbergen, nach dem Standpunkte der Kenntniss im Jahre 1872. (Giles Land, Kong Karls Land and the seabeds around Spitsbergen according to the knowledge in 1872.) Petermanns Geographische Mitteilungen 18, 111–112.

Pettersen K. 1884. Det europæiske Polarhav i Sommeren 1884. (The European Polar Sea during the summer of 1884.) Ymer 4, 223–232.

Phipps C.J. 1774. A voyage towards the North Pole. London: J. Nourse.

Poppey C. 1875 (1874). Polar-Karte enthaltend. (Polar map.) Unpaginated map in A. Stieler (1875): Handatlas. (Hand atlas.) 6th edn. Gotha: Justus Perthes.

Powell E.J. 1909. Arctic Ocean and Greenland Sea. From the latest information in the Hydrographic Department of the Admiralty. Large corrections September 1908. London: Davies, Bryer & Co.

Reichs-Marine-Amt 1907. Nördliches Eismeer, Barents see. (Northern Arctic Ocean, Barents Sea.) Nr. 155 (Tit. XIII Nr.31), Maßstab 1:2 000 000. Leipzig and Berlin: Gieseke & Devrient.

Samoylovich R.L. 1934. Vo l’dakh Arktiki: pokhod “Krasina” letom 1928 goda. (My Journey in the Arctic with Krasin during the summer of 1928.) Leningrad: Izdanie Vsesoyuznogo Arkticheskogo Instituta.

Tammiksaar E., Sukhova N.G. & Stone I.R. 1999. Hypothesis versus fact: August Petermann and polar research. Arctic 52, 237–244, https://doi.org/10.14430/arctic929.

van Keulen G. 1969–1970 (ca. 1714). Nieuwe afteekening van Het Eyland Spits-Bergen. (New map of the island of Spitsbergen.) Unpaginated map in J. van Keulen & G. van Keulen. (1969–70): De Nieuwe Groote Ligtende Zee-Fakkel, Amsterdam 1716–1753. (The new great shining sea torch, Amsterdam, 1716–1753.) Amsterdam: Theatrum Orbis Terrarum.

von Payer J. 1876. Die Österreichisch-ungarische Nordpol-Expedition in den Jahren 1872–1874. (The Austro-Hungarian North Pole Expedition in 1872–74.) Vienna: A. Hoelder.

Worsley F.A. 2003. Under sail in the frozen north. Santa Barbara: The Narrative Press.

Wråkberg U. 2015. Chapter 8. The politics of place names: a summation. In P.J. Capelotti (ed.): Proceedings of a Workshop on the Historic Place names of Franz Josef Land. Septentrio Conference Series 2015 (3). Pp. 69–89. Tromsø: Septentrio Conference and University Park, PA: The Polar Center, http://dx.doi.org/10.7557/5.3585.